Warning that Melton councillors could soon be bypassed over most planning decisions

Up to 90 per cent of Melton borough planning applications could be delegated to officers rather than being considered by elected councillors when new national guidelines come in at the end of October.

That was the stark warning planning committee chair Chris Evans gave colleagues at the latest full council meeting as they debated new government legislation aimed at speeding up the planning process.

Melton Borough Council chair, Councillor Chris Evans (right), and former chair, Councillor Allen Thwaitesplaceholder image
Melton Borough Council chair, Councillor Chris Evans (right), and former chair, Councillor Allen Thwaites

The new legislation was slammed as ‘appalling’ by Councillor Allen Thwaites, who put forward an amendment to council policy to enable councillors to retrospectively review delegated planning decisions, which was approved by the council.

Smaller applications, including housing schemes up to nine homes, will be delegated to officials under the terms of the new guidelines, which come in on October 31.

Many larger proposals could also bypass the committee, according to Councillor Evans, who is not aligned to any political party.

He told the meeting: “I’ve been through the planning records for the last year or two and 90 to 80 per cent of them, under this new law, will not come to planning committee.”

Councillor Evans said he estimated there could be a situation soon where the council’s planning committee only sits once or twice a year.

"This will put huge pressure on our officers because the public will soon recognise that they are the ones who will make all these decisions,” he added.

The amendments put forward by Councillor Thwaites (Independent) – and backed by 19 councillors, with one against and three abstentions – will give councillors the chance to review delegated decisions made on planning applications.

The changes do not give the planning committee the power to overturn delegated decisions but it provides for a standing agenda item to be included at every monthly meeting to allow members to retrospectively review what has been decided.

Councillors cannot call-in applications when a delegated decision has been made but they can give their comments on them.

The meeting was suspended for 30 minutes while the suggested changes to council policy were discussed with the council’s senior management and legal team.

Councillor Thwaites, a former chair of planning, told the meeting: “…elected members bring something to planning that isn’t always contained in current application reports or within the decision process: that’s local knowledge and public awareness.”

He argued: “If we’re going to have less ability to scrutinise individual applications, surely we should have more ability to scrutinise how the system itself is working.”

Councillor Thwaites highlighted a recent planning application which the council blocked because of local knowledge.

This was the proposed new car wash in the car park of the former B&H Midlands Services building off Norman Way.

Officers had recommended approving the scheme but, he said, no mention was made in their report of its proximity to the Age UK Gloucester House building where elderly people would have been negatively impacted by having a busy car wash nearby.

Councillor Thwaites said the amendments to the council’s planning policy were not overriding professional advice or ignoring planning rules, adding: “National legislation may change who makes the decision.

"It should not remove our responsibility to see what is being decided, understand why, and hold the process to account.”

News you can trust since 1859
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice