Pausing of births at Melton baby unit criticised as a 'sham' and 'disingenuous'

Pausing services at Melton Mowbray's baby unit has been called a ‘sham’ by local politicians after NHS bosses confirmed it was to permanently close down.

Campaigners and residents are outraged following the Leicester, Leicestershire and Rutland Integrated Care Board’s (LLR ICB) announcement that they have no plans to continue births at St Mary’s Birth Centre.

A march through Melton last August in support of St Mary's Birth Centreplaceholder image
A march through Melton last August in support of St Mary's Birth Centre

The announcement, made last month, comes after University Hospitals of Leicester (UHL) NHS Trust implemented a temporary six-month pause to all births from last summer while they decided the next steps.

Concerns included poor staffing and low usage, with 30 per cent of the staff unavailable and births dropping to fewer than two per week.

However, local politicians say the closure is just a cost-cutting measure with Melton Borough Council leader Pip Allnatt (Labour), telling the Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS): “I have no hesitation in saying that this decision is a cynical and long intended one aimed solely at cost reductions.

"It has nothing whatsoever to do with safety or choice. The so-called ‘consultation’ was a sham from start to finish.”

Other campaigners say the ICB’s handling of the situation signals ‘closure by the back door’.

Campaigner and councillor Helen Cliff, of Melton Sysonby ward (Labour), said: “It is our firm belief that the language of ‘temporary’ and ‘pause’ was always disingenuous and that our fears over the announcement last summer indicating closure by the back door, were in fact well founded.”

Following a Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG) consultation in 2020, the decision was taken to relocate birthing services from Melton to a centre at Leicester General Hospital (LGH).

In 2021, the stand-alone midwife-led unit was promised by UHL as part of the national New Hospitals Programme, but this has since been delayed by central government and the expected funding will not materialise until 2032. In 2023, the ICB assured residents that St. Mary’s would not close until the new unit was open.

A local campaign group, Save our NHS Leicester, organised rallies in response to the pause last summer and now say ICB’s intention to close the site is a ‘betrayal’ of previous promises.

Godfrey Jennings, group secretary, said: “While we accept that delays in capital funding have created challenges for our hospitals, we remain completely opposed to the abandonment of a stand-alone midwife led birth centre for the mothers of Leicester, Leicestershire and Rutland.

“Evidence shows that, for low-risk pregnancies, the outcomes for babies and mothers are very good at these centres. The loss of the post-natal beds is especially regretted given the importance of those beds, in particular, to mothers with additional needs.”

The ICB is currently engaging users of the service to inform decisions going forward.

A spokesperson said: “We know how important this issue is for local families and NHS colleagues.

"Before we confirm how we will enact the consultation outcome made in 2021, we want to hear from those most affected by the pause at St Mary’s.

“This is what we are currently engaging people on and all this feedback will help us make sure the next steps are fair, transparent, and shaped by local voices.”

Go to https://leicesterleicestershireandrutland.icb.nhs.uk/be-involved/smbc-engagement/ to give your feedback until Sunday’s deadline.

News you can trust since 1859
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice