Councillors join forces to condemn decision on Melton's second GP surgery
Melton councillors from across the political spectrum joined forces yesterday (Wednesday) to condemn the local health authority’s decision to pause plans for a second GP surgery in the town.
They spoke passionately at Leicestershire County Council’s latest health overview and scrutiny meeting which was attended by the chief executive of Leicester, Leicestershire and Rutland Integrated Care Board (ICB).


A report which went before the committee stated that there was ‘no evidence that Melton should be prioritised above other areas across LLR for investment in additional Primary Care service provision’.
It pointed out that there was only a 3.19 per cent increase in patient registrations at the town’s only GP surgery – Latham House Medical Practice – between 2020 and August 2025.


ICB representatives at the meeting, including chief executive Toby Saunders, argued that there were not currently enough potential new patients in the town to justify a second practice and that the board would work with Latham House to improve services and accessiblity to appointments there.
He did indicate that the situation may change when the thousands of new houses planned in Melton are built over the next decade and that the health board would monitor this.
His words failed to satisfy all four county councillors who represent Melton divisions – Conservatives Joe Orson and Bryan Lovegrove and Reform UK members Andrew Innes and Kerry Knight – plus Melton Borough Council’s Labour leader, Pip Allnatt, who asked a question as a member of the public.
Councillor Orson (Melton Wolds) told the meeting he felt ‘massively let down and Melton residents do too’ by the decision because in 2022, when he was borough council leader, he had agreed with the then ICB chairman to go ahead with a second GP surgery and ‘in my farming world a handshake is a deal’.


He said: “Melton only has four county councillors and yet we are all here today – this is the first time in over 20 years I’ve ever known that for Melton Mowbray for all to attend any scrutiny committee.
"So it goes to show the pressure that’s on us that is coming from our residents.”
Councillor Innes (Melton East) said: “I have residents coming to me saying ‘I am worried about my husband because he can’t get an appointment – if he’s got cancer how do we know?’
"My wife had to go to A&E twice because we couldn’t get appointments.


"Three years ago there was a need recognised for a practice and we’re now sitting years later with residents complaining that they can’t get blood tests and you have to wait weeks for follow-up appointments.
"There is chaos in Melton and that’s why four of us are sitting here – there is something not right in Melton.”
Councillor Lovegrove (Belvoir Division) said: “For at least a generation people have been saying that Latham House is broken.
"It is no wonder no more people are signing up to join Latham House because it feels like in Melton it is a sinking ship."
He added: “For generations people in Melton have said we will get a ring road and it is opening this spring.
“And for generations they’ve been saying Melton is going to get a second doctors’ surgery so let’s hope that’s not more generations down the line.
"We are losing the maternity unit and Melton residents have been crying out for a second surgery or more capacity in the town or the borough and it feels as if they are having backs turned on them because of the service they are getting at the moment.”
Councillor Knight (Melton West) said she wanted to see patients fined if they did not turn up for appointments at Latham House to deter them.
Addressing the ICB representatives, who said the Melton surgery was performing well and above national average guidelines on appointments, she said: “It says to me that there is something internal to that surgery, whether it be mismanagement or bad processes. You say you are working with the surgery to work it out. We can’t wait for a year, we certainly can’t wait two years for another surgery that might turn up or not.
Borough council leader, Councillor Allnatt pointed out in his public question that nearly 3,500 new homes were due to be built in the borough up to 2036, with the majority of those in the north and south of the town, in association with building of the distributor road.
He said this would increase the town’s population by up to 25 per cent and that ‘it would be naive to assume that the current modest level of new registrations for Latham House will continue at their current levels’.
Latest ICB figures show that total appointments offered via surgeries in the Melton, Syston and Vale Primary Care Network (PCN), from April to October 2025, was 289,084, representing a 6.3 per cent increase on the same period the year before. Around 60 per cent were face-to-face.
ICB representatives at the meeting agreed to a request to provide a breakdown of individual figures for Melton alone at a later date.
The board’s chief executive, Mr Saunders, told the meeting that it was very rare that a new GP practice would be set up from scratch.
He said a new surgery would need to have 5-6,000 patients registered to guarantee an operating cost of up to £1.5M a year.
Developer funding from Section 106 agreements was mainly used to extend existing surgeries, he said, as opposed to building new ones.
Mr Saunders said the large size of Latham House was not seen as a problem although the lack of choice for local patients was.
He pointed out that the Melton practice had already made changes to improve appointment availabilities, adding: “We recognise the challenges you describe about the challenges patients face.
"There are a lot of points you have made today that we will take away and discuss with Latham House.”